UNDP United Nations Development Programme برنامج الأمم المتحدة الإنمائي
Programme on Governance in the Arab Region برنامج إدارة الحكم في الدول العربية POGAR
Publications: Legislature
- Executive Summary
- Introduction
- I. Experiences of Institutional Development
  - 1. The Scopes and Methods of Institutional Development of Parliaments
  - 2. The Development in Internal Regulation of Parliament
  - 3. The Development of the System of Parliamentary Committees
- II. Practical Paradoxes and Problems
  - 1. Practical Suggestions to Improve the Listening Committees Performance
  - 2. The Development of Parliamentary Information and Research Units
  - 3. Developing the Parliamentary Library
  - 4. The Development of Parliamentary Training
  - 5. The Development of Parliamentary Information
- Epilogue: The Challenges and Important Domains of Institutional Development
- Annex 1: Table of Committees Comparison
- References
A Development Agenda for Arab Parliaments
Symposium on Arab Parliamentary Development
by Dr. Ali El- Sawi

Annex 1: Table of Committees Comparison

Argentina
- The Senate
- Chamber of Deputies

41
38
(Plus 4 common committees)
In both houses the leader is delegated to form committees and he takes into account proportional representation and the strength of the parties.
Bulgaria
- The National Council

18
Reflects the political weight of strong parties.
Canada
- The Senate
- House of Commons

13
20
Nine members are appointed at the beginning of the session by the classification committee to form the standing permanent committees. Special and ad-hoc committees are chosen by the House of Commons
Costa Rica
- Legislative Council

6
The structure reflects the relative strength of the leading party and the party divisions.
El Salvador
- Legislative Assembly

14
Same as Costa Rica
France
-The Senate
-The National Assembly

6
6
In both, the formation of committees reflects the proportional weight of the ruling party
Germany
- The Senate
- Chamber of Deputies

Chooses 24
Chooses 24
In both cases, the choice and proportions reflect the strength of parties
Hungary
- The National Assembly

11 standing permanent committees and 6 special ad-hoc ones
Reflecting the proportional representation and strength of parties
India
- The People’s Council
- The Council of Provinces

12

9
Plus 7 common committees and 17 permanent specialized committees
In both cases, appointment or election is made by the council through proposal or designation or candidacy through the leadership office
Ireland
- The Senate
-Chamber of Deputies

3 (by choice)
3
3 common committees
Choice of committees is made on the basis of designation by a classification committee appointed by the House which takes into account the relative strength of parties and non-party groups
Japan
- Consultative House
- Chamber of Deputies

17

20
In both, positions on committees are assigned by the leadership office on the basis of relative weight of parties
Jordan
- House of Notables
- Chamber of Deputies

17

20
Election of members takes place in a secret ballot
Namibia
- National Assembly

4 standing permanent committees
Candidacy is made via parties and announced by an official spokesman
Portugal
- Presidential Council

12 permanent committees
Proportion of members in committees reflects the strength of the parties
Romania
- The Senate
- Chamber of Deputies

14
14 plus one intelligence committee

Proportional representation in committees reflects strength of parties. Then each party decides who will represent it in each committee
Russia
- The Duma Council
- The Federal Council

23

13
In both the proportions are in line with party strength
Senegal
- The National Assembly

11
The appointment is by the Assembly based on proposals from heads of parliamentary blocs
Thailand
- House of Commons
- House of Lords

15

13
In both, election takes place and on the basis of the relative weight of each party
United Kingdom
-House of Commons

- House of Lords


30

14 plus 10 permanent branch committees
In the House of Commons, the Selection Committee picks the standing permanent committees and proposes 14 members to choose the branch committees which are to be appointed by the House. In the House of Lords, committees are formed on the basis of the advice given by he selection committee, except in the case of the reconciliation committee which is chosen upon the advice of the Chairman of the House of Lords.
United States
- The Senate



- The Lower House


16 permanent, 3 chosen, one special committee

19 permanent, 2 chosen 4 common committees (Four common between the upper and lower houses)
In both houses, election takes place and is based on the relative weight of the parties

Top of this page